Hedging Shrubs

What are the disadvantages of the Photinia Red Robin plant?

The main drawbacks of Photinia 'Red Robin': leaf spot, frequent trimming, size, frost-tender shoots, smelly flowers and toxicity, plus how to manage each one.

On this page
  1. Leaf spot disease
  2. Constant trimming to keep the red colour
  3. It gets bigger than many people expect
  4. Frost and wind damage to new growth
  5. The flowers smell unpleasant to many people
  6. Bare at the base with age
  7. Toxicity
  8. Less dense than some hedges
  9. Is photinia still worth planting?
  10. Alternatives to Photinia ‘Red Robin’

Photinia × fraseri ‘Red Robin’ is a popular evergreen hedge, but it has several drawbacks. The main disadvantages are:

  • Leaf spot disease, which can strip leaves in damp, humid conditions
  • Frequent trimming needed to keep the red colour
  • Large size if left unpruned, often 4 m or more
  • Frost- and wind-tender new growth
  • Flowers with a smell many people find unpleasant
  • A tendency to go bare at the base with age if poorly managed
  • Toxic leaves and berries, a concern mainly for grazing animals

None of these rules photinia out, but together they mean it’s a plant to choose deliberately rather than by default. Here’s what each one means in practice.

Leaf spot disease

The most serious problem is photinia leaf spot, caused by the fungus Entomosporium mespili. It shows as small red spots on young leaves. The spots enlarge, develop grey or brown centres, and can merge into large blotches. Infected leaves fall, and a hedge hit hard several years in a row can become thin and weakened.

The disease is worst in warm, humid weather and where leaves stay wet: shady corners, overcrowded plantings and hedges watered with sprinklers. It’s a particular problem in the south-eastern United States, where many red-tip photinia hedges have been badly damaged, but it also occurs in Britain and Ireland.

What helps: plant in sun with good airflow, water the soil rather than the leaves, and clear up fallen infected leaves. Improving conditions usually does more than spraying.

Constant trimming to keep the red colour

The red colour only appears on new shoots. After a few weeks those leaves turn green, so a hedge left untrimmed is mostly green for much of the year. Keeping it red means trimming at least twice in the growing season, often in late spring and again in late summer. Each trim triggers a fresh flush.

What helps: accept a greener hedge, or plan the trimming in from the start. Our photinia hedge guide sets out a simple schedule.

It gets bigger than many people expect

‘Red Robin’ is often sold as a compact shrub, but unpruned it can reach 4–5 m tall and nearly as wide. Planted in a narrow bed or next to a path, it can soon outgrow the space.

What helps: keep up with trimming, or choose a compact form such as ‘Little Red Robin’ for small spaces.

Frost and wind damage to new growth

Established plants are reasonably hardy in most of Britain and Ireland and in USDA zones 7–9. The soft red shoots are less tough, though. Late spring frosts can blacken them, and cold, drying winds can scorch them. In very cold winters older leaves may also be damaged.

What helps: plant in a sheltered spot, and don’t trim late in autumn, which would push out soft growth just before frosts.

The flowers smell unpleasant to many people

If not trimmed off, photinia carries flat clusters of small white flowers in spring. Many people find their scent unpleasant, and it’s noticeable close to seating areas or open windows. Regular spring trimming removes most flower buds, which also removes the smell.

Bare at the base with age

Like many hedges, photinia can go thin and leggy at the bottom if it’s always clipped wider at the top, or if shade from neighbouring plants starves the lower branches of light.

What helps: trim the hedge so it’s slightly narrower at the top than at the base. Older, leggy plants usually respond to firm pruning in spring. See how to renovate an overgrown hedge.

Toxicity

Photinia is in the rose family. Like cherry laurel, its leaves contain compounds that can release cyanide when chewed. Serious poisoning is mainly a risk for grazing animals such as horses and cattle that might eat large amounts. Don’t plant it along a paddock boundary, and don’t leave clippings where livestock can reach them. The berries shouldn’t be eaten by people. If you’re concerned about pets or children, ask your vet or a poisons information service for advice.

Less dense than some hedges

A well-kept photinia hedge gives good screening. It’s usually less solid than a mature yew or laurel hedge, though, and right after a trim it can look more open. If complete privacy is the main goal, those denser plants may suit you better.

Is photinia still worth planting?

For many gardens, yes. Photinia is evergreen, moderate to fast growing, tolerant of a range of soils, and the spring colour is hard to match. It suits gardeners who enjoy regular trimming and have a sunny, airy site. It’s a poorer choice for shady, damp, enclosed gardens, for hot and humid regions where leaf spot is common, and for anyone wanting a hedge they can trim once a year and forget.

Alternatives to Photinia ‘Red Robin’

If the drawbacks outweigh the appeal, consider:

  • Portuguese laurel: dense, formal, shade tolerant, with red leaf stalks
  • Griselinia: fresh green, good on the coast
  • Escallonia: evergreen with summer flowers, good on the coast
  • Purple-leaved shrubs: if colour is the main attraction, consider a purple leaf plum hedge, though it’s deciduous

For a wider comparison, see our guide to choosing evergreen hedge plants.

The complete guide to hedging shrubs

Evergreen Hedge Plants: Choosing and Planting a Hedge
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →