Dry shade under trees is one of the hardest spots in any garden. The shade is the easy part, because plenty of shrubs tolerate low light. The real difficulty is that the soil beneath a tree is often dry, full of roots and short of nutrients for much of the year. The right shrubs, planted carefully, can still make these areas look good.
Why dry shade under trees is so difficult
Several things work against plants under trees at once:
- Rain shadow: a dense canopy intercepts much of the rain, especially light showers, and sheds it towards the edge of the canopy rather than the trunk.
- Root competition: trees take up large amounts of water and nutrients, and many have dense networks of fine roots near the surface.
- Low light: in summer, when shrubs most need energy, the canopy is at its densest.
- Leaf litter: fallen leaves can smother low plants, though they also break down into useful organic matter.
There’s also a paradox here. Most shade plants have broad, thin leaves that lose water easily, while most drought-tolerant plants are adapted to sun. Few plants are naturally good at both, which is why the list of reliable shrubs is fairly short.
Which trees are hardest to plant under?
Some trees are much harder neighbours than others. As a general guide:
- Most difficult: trees with dense canopies and shallow, fibrous roots, such as beech, birch, sycamore, horse chestnut and Norway maple, and large conifers, including Leyland cypress hedges.
- Easier: trees with lighter canopies or deeper roots, such as oak, ash, rowan and many smaller ornamental trees.
Evergreen trees cast shade and intercept rain all year, so the ground beneath them tends to be driest of all.
The best shrubs for dry shade
Aucuba japonica
Probably the most widely recommended shrub for dry shade. Its glossy, often gold-speckled leaves bring light to dark areas, and once established it copes with dry soil, poor soil and very little sun. It dislikes only waterlogging. See our Aucuba japonica guide.
Butcher’s broom (Ruscus aculeatus)
A low, spiny UK native that grows naturally in dry woodland. It is slow and prickly, but almost indestructible in dry shade, and female plants carry red berries.
Oregon grape (Mahonia aquifolium)
A low, spreading evergreen with holly-like leaves, yellow spring flowers that bees visit, and blue-black berries. It’s tough enough for dry shade and gradually forms a thicket, which makes useful ground cover.
Euonymus fortunei
Cheap, cheerful and very adaptable. Variegated forms such as ‘Emerald Gaiety’ and ’Emerald ‘n’ Gold’ form low mounds that lighten dark areas. Planted against a trunk or wall, it may climb.
Box-leaved honeysuckle (Lonicera pileata)
A low, spreading evergreen with small dark leaves on horizontal, tiered branches. It grows to around 60cm tall and copes with dry shade and poor soil.
Christmas box (Sarcococca confusa)
Strictly happier in soil that doesn’t dry out completely, but once established it copes with fairly dry shade, and its scented winter flowers are a real bonus. Give it extra care and water while it settles in.
Cherry laurel ‘Otto Luyken’
A compact, low, spreading form of cherry laurel with narrow glossy leaves and white flower spikes in spring. Like its larger parent, it tolerates shade and dry soil well once established.
Holly
Native holly copes with dry, shady woodland conditions in the wild and grows slowly beneath trees. Plain green forms are most tolerant of deep shade. Only females berry, and only with a male nearby.
Spurge laurel (Daphne laureola)
A modest native evergreen around 1m tall with glossy leaves and small yellow-green flowers in late winter. It grows in woodland, including on chalk. All parts are poisonous.
Snowberry (Symphoricarpos)
A deciduous shrub with white or pink berries that last into winter. It’s tough enough for dry shade but spreads by suckers and can become invasive, so choose a well-behaved cultivar and keep it in check.
Shrubs to avoid in dry shade
Some popular shade shrubs are a poor fit for dry ground under trees, because they need reliably moist roots:
- hydrangeas (see our guide to hydrangeas for shade for where they do thrive)
- camellias and rhododendrons
- pieris
- skimmia, which can do well in moist shade (see our Skimmia japonica guide) but often struggles in very dry soil
How to plant under a tree without harming it
Trees are easy to damage by careless digging, so take a gentle approach:
- Plant in autumn. Winter rain helps new roots establish before the next summer.
- Choose small plants. Young plants in small pots fit into gaps between tree roots and establish better than large specimens in big root balls.
- Dig small pockets between roots with a trowel, rather than digging large holes. Avoid cutting any substantial roots.
- Add a little organic matter to each planting pocket, such as leafmould or garden compost.
- Don’t raise the soil level over tree roots by more than a few centimetres, and never pile soil or mulch against the trunk. Burying roots and bark can harm the tree.
- Water each plant thoroughly after planting.
If the tree is protected, for example by a Tree Preservation Order or because you live in a conservation area, check with your local council before doing work that might affect it.
Watering and mulching for the first two years
Even tough shrubs need help while they establish:
- During dry spells in the first two summers, water each shrub thoroughly about once a week. A heavy soak that reaches the roots is far more useful than a light sprinkle.
- Sinking a short length of pipe or an upturned plastic bottle beside each plant can help get water down to the roots.
- Mulch in late winter or spring, while the soil is still moist, with about 5cm of leafmould, compost or bark, keeping it clear of stems and the tree trunk.
- Leave some fallen leaves in place to rot down, but rake them off low evergreens that might be smothered.
Let more light and rain in
If a tree casts very heavy shade, crown lifting (removing the lower branches) or crown thinning by a qualified tree surgeon can let in more light and rain. That usually widens the range of plants you can grow. Ask the tree surgeon what is appropriate for the species and its health.
Groundcover to go with your shrubs
Low perennials and ground covers that cope with dry shade can fill gaps between shrubs. Commonly used examples include Geranium macrorrhizum, epimediums, Euphorbia amygdaloides var. robbiae (which spreads), lesser periwinkle (Vinca minor) and ivy. Bulbs such as cyclamen and snowdrops also make use of the light before the canopy fills out.
For more options beyond dry shade, see our main guide to shrubs for shade, or compare the toughest options in what is the most shade-tolerant evergreen shrub?